Brooklyn-Inspired Shabbos Menu & Egg Cream Recipe

This menu is inspired by my Jewish father's childhood stories of growing up in Brooklyn. He taught me how to make an authentic egg cream when I was 11 years old, introduced me to halvah and the wonders of toasted kasha, and to appreciate a good deli sandwich. 

  • Brooklyn-Inspired Menu:
    • Mains (a buffet-style spread of knish and/or sandwich fixings):
      • Knishes (recipe here)
      • Kasha varnishkes (recipe here)
      • Sandwich bar (guests can build their own sandwich):
        • Rye bread and/or challah
        • Faux deli slices (e.g., Tofurky deli slices)
        • Hummus (some may prefer this to faux meat)
        • Onions, sliced
        • Tomatoes, sliced
        • Bell peppers, sliced
        • Lettuce
        • Pickles
        • Pickled peppers (I love Jeff's Garden's peperoncini and banana pepper rings
        • Olives
        • Mustard
        • Horseradish (Gold's)
        • Oil & vinegar
        • Salt & pepper
        • Dried oregano
      • Matzo ball soup (keep in slow cooker; recipe here)
      • Pickled beets
      • Deli salads (to save time, I like to purchase directly from the kosher market deli or just make a quick and easy Israeli salad):
        • Pasta salad (e.g., orzo)
        • Cucumber salad (with the thinly sliced cucumbers and onions, or an Israeli salad)
        • Cabbage salad (any kind)
        • Bean salads (e.g., three bean salad)
    • Desserts (choose one):
      • Egg cream (add about 1 inch of pareve chocolate syrup into a tall glass, then add 2-3 inches of non-dairy milk, then add seltzer -- I like to add the seltzer and stir at the same time; see procedure here)
      • Root beer float (any non-dairy ice cream with a natural root beer such as Virgil's)
      • Halva
Egg cream that is mostly foam

A tray of cooked knishes next to a bowl of cooked, cooled knishes

A bowl of kasha varnishkes